There’s something irresistible about a story where the bad guys just can’t win—especially when the bad guys are trying to commit murder. That’s the hook of Murdering Michael Malloy, a forthcoming crime thriller and dark comedy that draws from a notorious true-crime case from Depression-era New York. The project just got a lot more interesting with the addition of Andy Garcia, Asia Kate Dillon, Frank Whaley, Michael Rispoli, and James Madio to a cast already featuring Tim Roth and Timothy Spall.
Production is slated to begin in the first quarter of 2027, with Archstone Entertainment handling worldwide sales. Raymond De Felitta (City Island, Two Family House) is directing from a screenplay he co-wrote with David Zellerford.
The film’s premise is as darkly comic as it is shocking: Tim Roth plays Tony Marino, a struggling bar owner who, alongside his cohort Bastogne (Garcia), takes out a life-insurance policy on a neighborhood drunk named Michael Malloy (Spall). The plan is simple—kill Malloy for the payout. The problem? Malloy seems utterly impossible to kill. As Marino’s increasingly desperate schemes fail, the two men forge an unexpected bond, building toward a haunting final act of sacrifice against the backdrop of the Great Depression.
Also worth a look: American Hustle’ producer George Parra signs on for true-crime film about Miami kingpin Louis Ippolito and Vanessa Williams and Stan Zimmerman bring real suicide notes to screen in New York docudrama.
De Felitta brings serious credentials to the project. His Academy Award–nominated short Bronx Cheers led to his feature debut Café Society, which premiered in Cannes’ Directors’ Fortnight. Both Two Family House and City Island earned Audience Awards at Sundance and Tribeca, respectively. His later work includes the crime drama Rob the Mob and the ABC miniseries Madoff, which earned him a Directors Guild of America nomination.
Behind the scenes, Stephen Endelman—who is also composing the score—produces alongside Dan Grodnik, Louise Chater, and Jeff Wallner and Tom Zheng of Harbor Lights Entertainment. Michael Torchia serves as executive producer. Casting is by Shakyra Dowling, with legal representation from James Pacitti and Lee & Thompson.
Garcia, recently named a 2026 Kennedy Center Honoree, is an Academy Award nominee known for The Godfather Part III, The Untouchables, and the Ocean’s Eleven franchise. He’s also a Grammy and Latin Grammy Award winner, repped by CAA and managed by Linden Entertainment. Dillon earned Critics Choice Award nominations for their groundbreaking role as Taylor Mason in Billions and appeared in Orange Is the New Black and John Wick: Chapter 3 – Parabellum. They are represented by Independent Artist Group and managed by Authentic Talent and Literary Management. Whaley (Pulp Fiction, Field of Dreams, JFK) is with Atrium Talent and Karen Forman Management. Rispoli, known for playing Jackie Aprile in The Sopranos and his role in The Deuce, is represented by Innovative Artists and Principal Entertainment LA. Madio (The Basketball Diaries, Band of Brothers) is with Harden Curtis Kirsten Riley Agency and managed by Amplified.
Why it matters: This project resurrects a bizarre and little-known true-crime story that feels tailor-made for our current appetite for darkly comedic, character-driven thrillers. With a stacked cast and a director with major festival pedigree, Murdering Michael Malloy could be a standout entry in the growing trend of period crime stories that find humanity in the most unlikely places.
I Charles
Falco Ink.
+1 212-445-7100






